makeup stocking stuffer


The Best Drugstore Makeup Stocking Stuffers

makeup stocking stuffers cover


I love big gifts, but makeup stocking stuffers have a special place in my heart. If you’ve read my Holiday Gift Guide for Beauty and Makeup Enthusiasts, you know that there’s something for everyone on your list, from a great book for makeup beginners to a little something for trendsetters. But, if you’re looking for something a little bit smaller to stuff into a stocking, the drugstore makeup aisles are the perfect place to go!


The problem is, there are soooo many options available at the drugstore that it can be really confusing and overwhelming. That’s why I decided to create this list, to help you on your gift-buying journey. In this list, you will find my current drugstore makeup faves… I hope it helps!

Learn Makeup with Natalie Setareh

Best Drugstore Makeup Stocking Stuffers: Foundation

Revlon Color Stay Foundation & Loreal True Match Foundation

Revlon and Loreal Foundations

I used both of these foundations in the early days of my makeup artist business because of their high-performance and low price point. If you can’t find an exact color match (and you can afford it), pick up a few shades so the recipient can custom blend their own foundation! I like applying these foundations with a brush, and my favorite is Senna’s Foundation Brush.

Looking for inclusive makeup no matter your genre and lots of foundation shades?! Check out 10 of the most inclusive makeup brands out there.


Almay Tinted Moisturizer

almay tinted moisturizer

Almay Tinted Moisturizer is perfect for the person on your list who doesn’t want or necessarily need full coverage. I like this option because the camouflage color technology in these bad boys is out of this world and actually does “blend” beautifully into your natural skin tone. You can always wear an additional layer if you want a little more coverage. 

By the way, some of the leading and top makeup artists in the world rave about Almay –– their tonality is pretty great.

Best Drugstore Makeup Stocking Stuffers: Makeup Brushes


Real Techniques Beauty Sponge

real techniques beauty sponge

This sponge has nearly the same performance as its famous “pink” older sister but at half the price. Remember to take care of your makeup sponges and they’ll take care of you! 


Real Techniques Setting Powder Brush

real techniques setting brush

This brush has made it into nearly every gift and product guide I’ve ever produced. I love this brush so much – its shape makes it great for setting powder in small areas but you can also buff the foundation in with this brush, contour/shape, blush, and highlight with it, too. I have five on hand at any given time. 

If you want to learn more about makeup brushes, check out this post on makeup brushes and get my Makeup Brush Guide.



Oh and, by the way, these are some of the makeup tools I recommend in my complete Essential Makeup Tools Guide. By the way, this Essential Makeup Tools Guide is FREE with the purchase of my book, Be Your Own Makeup Artist.


Best Drugstore Makeup Stocking Stuffers: Lips

EOS Lip Balm

EOS lip balm teal

These little lip balm balls are just as cute and fun as they are practical. They give your lips this really light shine effect, but it’s not glossy. EOS Lip Balms are perfect for those who like a soft and organic lip balm.



NYX Lip Liners

NYX Lip Liners

I am pretty sure I have every color of the NYX lip liners in my pro kit. They are staples and you don’t have to feel bad using them every day because the price point isn’t painful like some of the high-end brands. Plus, they are wood so they sharpen easily!


Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick

Maybelline Super Stay Liquid Lipstick

You know I’m not a huge fan of liquid lipstick because the formulas are extremely drying and can be, with use over long periods of time, damaging to the lips. This particular formula is one that I’m happy to recommend mostly because Maybelline turned to pro makeup artists to help formulate and create this particular product line and a color story –– so you know you are getting a well-thought-out and executed lipstick at a fraction of the cost of a department store or prestige brands. 



Natalie Setareh Makeup For Beginners Online Course

The ultimate gift for makeup beginners! A 5 day crash course in everything you need to know about achieving a classic, everyday basic makeup look.

Best Drugstore Makeup Stocking Stuffers: Blushes and Bronzers

Milani Baked Blushes & Milani Lip Glosses

Milani Baked Blush and Lip Gloss

These baked blushes rival some of the top-dollar baked blushes I’ve used over the years and the color pays off is amazing. The finish is also so gorgeous and flattering. A definite must! And their lip glosses offer a perfect, dynamic top coat that isn’t too sticky or too glittery — flattering all the way. I’m glad the big influencers haven’t ruined this cult-favorite for makeup artists brand…yet.


Physicians Formula Butter Bronzer (for light to medium skin tones)

Physicians Formula Butter Bronzer

I did an entire drugstore bronzer haul (read here) and when I think about drugstore bronzers, I still haven’t forgotten about this one! Physicians Formula Butter Bronzer adds some warmth and sun-kiss to your skin without harmful rays and it smells like a tropical vacation!


Cover Girl Queen – Ebony Bronze (for deep and melanin-rich skin tones)

Cover Girl Queen - Ebony Bronze

Want to shade and bronze your gorgeous melanin skin tone? This is your girl. Cover Girl Queen – Ebony Bronze is a really good bronzer for deep skin tones. Affordable, simple yet effectively packaged, pigmented and it blends nicely. 


Best Drugstore Makeup Stocking Stuffers: Eyes 


Essence Mascara

Essence Big Lashes Volume Boost Mascara


I’m always saying that you are mostly paying for brand recognition and packaging when you buy mascara. The actual quality is hardly ever reflected in the price –– and this mascara is proof of that. I carry many drugstore mascaras in my pro kit and this is one of my faves!


Did you like this list?


Don’t forget to save the image below on your “Makeup Tips” Pinterest board to go back to it whenever you need to. While you’re there, follow me on Pinterest to get even more makeup tips just like this!


drugstore makeup stocking stuffers gift guide

Have a beauty Question?

Been answering your beauty questions since 2014!

When you ask, not only will you get the answer but I'll also add you to my biweekly newsletter.


Your contact form was successfully submitted and I will be in touch within 48 hours. I respond to emails M-F from Germany time (aka 9-5 UTC+1:00). Feel free to call/text me for urgent or last minute appointments
 +49 151 65874996. 

P.S. If you asked me a beauty question, if I don't immediately know the answer, I must thoroughly research every question I receive, and sometimes do not have an immediate answer or I need clarity on unlisted ingredients in certain beauty products, sometimes getting a clear answer takes up to 3 weeks... have patience, it'll be worth it!

Be Your Own Makeup Artist

order a copy

the best reference book

Learn Makeup in 5 Days

take the course

a game changing course

elevate your image digital guide

get your copy

free guide

MUA business templates

save time in your business

for pro muas

learn makeup in 5 days!

save your seat

makeup for beginners

create your signature look

learn more today

1:1 personalized coaching

Popular resources

Beauty is about perception, not about make-up. I think the beginning of all beauty is knowing and liking oneself. You can't put on make-up, or dress yourself, or do you hair with any sort of fun or joy if you're doing it from a position of correction.

kevyn aucoin